Skip to content

Why You Should Think Twice Before Buying a New Car

If you’ve been out lately kicking tires, thinking of owning a shiny new car, chock full of the latest innovations like rear cameras, and voice activated commands—think again.

Buying a new car now, some say, would be worse than buying a new horse just as the first Fords drove off the assembly line, and worse by far than buying a three year old iphone.

Here’s why:

There is a huge cultural shift in all areas of the technological world, and it is led by the car. We know it is happening by the quickening of news and predictions about it, but we don’t know how fast, or in what form, the changes will come.

Change is always preceded by hype, and there is an enormous amount of hype right now about change in the automotive world. While its difficult to sort it all out, here are some major trends:

The rise of the electric car:

We hear that the gas-powered car is on its way out, that cars powered by electricity will account for 35% of all cars in the next two decades. Here is an article (with an amazing chart!) about electric vehicles , by Tom Randall, writing for Bloomberg:

“In the next few years, Tesla, Chevy, and Nissan plan to start selling long-range electric cars in the $30,000 range. Other car makers and tech companies are investing billions on dozens of new models. By 2020, some of these will cost less and perform better than their gasoline counterparts. The aim would be to match the success of Tesla’s Model S, which now outsells its competitors in the large luxury class in the U.S.”

The growing popularity of car sharing:

We are being told that car sharing will soon make car ownership a thing of the past. Fleets like Uber, Lyft and Car2Go are already here, reports say:

More than 80,000 car-sharing vehicles were operating in urban centers around the world in 2015. It’s a rapidly escalating phenomena, since Millennials are putting off or just not buying cars.

The advancement of the self-driving car:

And, if that’s not enough, we are alerted to the fact that the self-driving car is already in use in several areas of the world. In a series of articles exploring the future of transport, the Economist Intelligence Unit writes:

“Self-driving cars are expected to be on the roads more quickly than was anticipated just a few years ago, and in greater numbers. Forecasts vary, as they always do, but the emerging consensus among the industry’s larger players is that, at minimum, fleet vehicles—trucks, taxis, and buses—that can take control and make independent decisions, i.e. SEA level 3, will be in use by the end of this decade. ”

And this, from the Globe and Mail:

“And while enhancing mobility and safety as a benefit to society, the consequence of mass acceptance of AVs may mean fewer jobs for truck, bus and taxi drivers, personal-injury lawyers, insurers, automotive repair technicians and others.

Nonetheless, the technology is coming, sure as snow in winter.”

And now, for the big question:

The world of car ownership is on shifting ground, that’s clear. The big question—the one that keeps us all on the edges of our seats—is the question of the pace of this shift.

Some researchers, like Jack Hitt, at the Smithsonian, think change will be slow:

“And this is how the cultural shift happens. It’s natural to think of innovation as happening in some instantaneous transformative way, but the transition to our own future will likelier involve a great mix of evolving technologies—a transportation landscape populated with smart cars, autonomous cars and, muses Fernando Suarez, a professor at Northeastern University’s School of Business, “maybe flying cars for some longer distances, and much better public transportation, and a dedicated bike lane, too.” The revolution will come, but you may not notice it until it’s happened.”

And some think that this time it’s different, that change will come rapidly. Here’s what David Galland of Garret/Galland Research says:

“… the technology adoption cycle has been steadily compressing. While it took approximately 50 years for electricity to be adopted by 60% of US households, it took cell phones only about 10 years and smartphones only about five years to reach the same penetration.”

I agree with David Galland, that technological changes are coming faster than ever before. Innovations in the automotive field are already in play, and the hype about them seems to be escalating. I’m not completely sold though, that the automotive shift will affect our age group. Just in case, though, I’ll keep repairing my old Nissan, rather than turning it in for a new one!

33 thoughts on “Why You Should Think Twice Before Buying a New Car”

  1. Aaack! I’m thinking about trading in my 14 year old Subaru for a new one which will probably be my last car. I tend to love my cars and keep them for a long time, so I want what I want, and prefer “stick” as I have always driven stick. They are getting pretty hard to come by these days. Also, I do NOT want a black interior!
    Vee shall zee vot ‘appens.

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Yes. vee shall zee…but if you do trade in your old Subaru for a new car, it will most likely be your last car, before the great ‘shift’!

  2. I have a 2001 Honda Civic which I love but have been thinking about getting a new used car. I’ve never had a new one. Maybe the new technology will mean that “regular” cars will be cheaper! 🙂

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Yes, Djan, the old cars will be cheaper, but the buzz is, that insurance for regular cars will escalate. We can’t win!

  3. Two things I think would be neat: an electric car that I could charge from solar panels on my roof, and a car in which I could sit and read while it drives me where I want to go. Without being killed, of course.

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Hmmm, I like both of those ideas! Older people will be enthusiastic users of the self-driving car, when it arrives!

      1. “computer” self driving…hmmmm. How many time does your computer crash? I’m just sayin’. Gussie agrees, too =^..^=

  4. I don’t know if you have anything like it in Canada, but here in the U.S., Zipcar is an other alternative. You sign up for a nominal membership fee, and can rent a car for as little or as long as you like. even to just go shopping.

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Yes, I have heard about Zipcar, but haven’t researched it. It will most definitely be a worthwhile alternative, when we are truly ready to change our thinking about cars. Thanks, Virginia!

  5. Apart from all that you say, a big factor is sheer economics. For city dwellers like me, it does not make economic sense to buy an automobile which sits in the garage most of the time when I can access three aggregators here for a cab that will take me anywhere I want to go to and from there another one to bring me back at whatever time of the day or night that I want. The ubiquitous autorickshaws are a second line of defence if other public transportation is not available.

    No, I shan’t be buying a new car ever at all. What I have will simply sit in the garage to establish occupation rights!

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      You are lucky to have so many choices! It seems hard to believe, but some cities simply aren’t very organized in providing public transportation, and cabs are very expensive. But new alternatives are turning up, as some of my readers have suggested!

        1. Still the Lucky Few

          Good article, and breakdown of expenses! But, in all fairness, it doesn’t address the whole picture—only compares cost of owning a car, compared to cab and Uber expense. A good read, though, since I’ve never seen such an analysis of the pros and cons of car ownership.

  6. I bought a Nissan Leaf when they first came out and I LOVED IT! Unfortunately, it was totaled when someone ran a red light and hit me (I was fine, but since they crushed the front where the charging port was it wasn’t possible to have it repaired). Anyway, stupid me decided to buy a new gas-powered car. I’ve had it for four years and don’t like it at all. I’ve been thinking about selling it (even though I usually keep my cars for 10+ years) and getting a used Leaf. Having an electric-powered vehicle makes so much sense for us right now. It’s great for doing little errands around town, which is our typical driving. If we need to drive further or haul anything, we can use my husband’s car.

    I agree with you that there will be some incredible innovations coming soon (that’s why I’d go with a used car for now).

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      I would guess that you paid a high price for the Leaf, since it was a relatively new arrival on the automotive scene. I think that a used Leaf would be a good choice for now, and you can keep an eye on new innovations as they become mainstream. It’s an exciting time to be living in, with so many choices unfolding!

  7. My 6-year-old Forester has all of 14,000 miles on it and I expect it will be my last car. Still, I’m envious of the new safety features and conveniences like auto braking for front crashes, side view mirrors with blind spot warnings, lane drift warnings, warning beeps when backing up, auto parallel parking, etc. And certainly these things are more important for aging drivers than for younger generations. I don’t drive enough to think about the savings with electric power, and I’m a long way from trusting self-driving cars. But I’m as awed as anyone at the speed with which these changes are overtaking us.

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Great comment, Susan! Looks like your Forester will last a long time, and you will be managing without all of the new, jazzy innovations. It’s a process, and you may find yourself pressured, through rising insurance rates for old cars, and maintenance expenses, to trade for a more modern, possibly electric car. Whatever you choose to do, I hope it works out for you, and that you are comfortable with your decisions!

  8. I haven’t got a car at all now…to date I’m used “walking, bus and train services (occasional ferry)

    But I’m told that quite a few of the younger generation are not even getting a drivers license (I’m in New Zealand) and rely on what I do plus Uber/taxi type services…

    Getting a license is one thing, buying a car usually credit and then adding all the regular things required – besides servicing but roadworthiness and other general gov’t taxes – and of course insurance. As rummuser said, your car may not be used all that much, and with all these extra $ you could call a “cab, have someone else drive you direct to wherever” -no problems having to find a carpark usually with a meter as well…

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Owning a car is part of the North American mindset, probably stemming from the days when towns and farms were far apart, and miles were traveled from one place to the next in order to conduct business and accomplish things. That is changed now, since most of our population lives in urban areas, so Uber, buses, taxis, and walking are more feasible—these modes seem to work well with the younger generation.

      1. similar mindset here as well, people my age (well when I gave up the car) thought I was nuts…they said “how will you get around?” – then some others who have traveled overseas, come back and make this remark “you would’ve been so proud of me, going about on the public transport”

        cycling is quite popular here as well, not always for getting to work through, much leisure sort of cycling. New cycleways popping up as well (at least in urban centres)

  9. We live in outer suburbs so most of my grandchildren saved for their first car as soon as they got their first after school part time job. Passing their ‘test’ and getting a car at 18 was their passage into adulthood. I’m not sure any of them are looking at all these new options that may or may not eventuate – they need to get to work or adult schooling on time (and safely) so no old ‘bombs’ for them.

    Personally I think it will be older more mature ‘well heeled’ drivers/ inner city dwellers who will be considering these options

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      It makes sense, Cathy, that older drivers would take to the newer ways of getting around—after all they can usually take more time to arrange transportation. But research is telling us that the Millennials are the group that is embracing Uber and car sharing, and cycling. Much of their motivation is lack of money, but they also seem more alert to preservation of the environment.

  10. Once again, Diane, you have educated me. You have a knack for choosing interesting topics, researching them, and presenting them in a concise and understandable format. This was fascinating reading. I doubt my life in the rural west will be impacted by the changes as quickly as other places, but I hope so.

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      You are right, Aunt Beulah—most changes always come first to urban areas, and later to rural societies. Except perhaps the adoption of mechanized farming implements. Once farmers could see the benefits of planting and reaping their products (and milking cows), new applications really took off!

  11. I expect to keep the car I have for as long as I’m able to drive. Have various options here for transportation when I can no longer drive. Friends have chosen to lease a car for the first time. Car has many of the tech features which enables the husband to resume driving again as he had some peripheral vision issues with one eye, reflexes slightly slower, so now sensors will accommodate if he’s too slow reacting — has other features, too. Wife carefully monitoring him is now comfortable with him behind the wheel after they did extensive practice and learning operation system — says she loves to drive car, too. They keep up with tech so will be in a position to either purchase this one, or move to future car with tech advances. I always wanted a car/boat/plane so I could go anywhere!

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      It’s clear to me that older people will be the ones to benefit from these new advances. I’ll love the self-driving car when it gets here!

  12. Yeah, Another Blogger

    Ah, I don’t see any reason not to buy a new car, gas-powered or not. The technology doesnt scare me off (the sticker prices might, though!).

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      I would think the technology would be more user-friendly than ever, given that a cross section of people, with no tech knowledge whatever, would be using the new cars. And yes, they are expensive!

Comments are closed.

© 2024 Diane Dahli All Rights Reserved | WordPress site by Quadra Street Designs