Skip to content

Women Are Rising in Droves in Government—Does This Mean Patriarchy is Dead?

It’s almost two years now since women all over the world took to the streets in the hundreds of thousands to protest the election of Donald Trump, and to challenge patriarchy.  Throughout that year and the next they continued their marches, speaking against sexual misconduct, determined to get their message across.

In November of this year, 121 women were elected to the US congress, ending male domination of that institution for as long as it has existed.

Are these two events linked? And will the energy and focus of their actions mean the end of patriarchy in the US?

We knew it could happen

It became clear during the lead-up to the election, that women were poised to make significant electoral gains in this election. The media was buzzing with news that scores of women were signing up to put their names on the ballot.

For many older women, who tried and failed over the decades, to break through the glass ceiling of corporate and political patriarchy, this was an exciting prospect. We knew, deep down, that this time was different—the massive woman’s marches and the #MeToo movement had set the stage for change.

What is becoming increasingly evident to everyone now, after the election, is that the protests were only part of this massive movement. Thousands of other women were working locally, nationally and globally to bring about political change. Many of them had busy lives, but they made time for this work between dropping off children at school, caring for their parents, and sometimes holding more than one job.

They were not alone. They were assisted by powerful women already in the political arena, like Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren, who said:

“Women who had never run for anything stepped up to put their names on the ballot. They ignored the party bosses who said they should wait their turn. They ignored the consultants who said they should cover up their tattoos and smile more, and they ignored the powerful men of the Republican Party who never took them seriously anyway. They refused to let anyone shut them up or stand in their way, and that is how real change begins.”

We have been here before

The rise of women in all areas previously dominated by men is not a new idea. Women have been working and hoping for this for decades. Our mothers and grandmothers lived with the reality of male patriarchy every day of their lives.

But we could not have predicted the extent of the disruption during the past few months, and we could not have predicted the intensity of the #MeToo movement, which was, essentially, a protest about sexual abuse of women.

The movement, already in motion, gained momentum with the election of Donald Trump, which many women saw as yet another unqualified man taking a job not rightfully his, and pushing aside the person who could do it better. It was a major demonstration against what they knew, in their hearts, was a grave injustice—and it made the world stand still and pay attention.

It’s recognized now that the energy for this movement came from deep within the history of women—their survival, their work, and the quest for personal independence.

What the election of Donald Trump really meant

What Donald Trump represented, and what he still represents, is the unequal balance of power given to unqualified, undeserving, and ill-equipped men.

Rather than give power to a woman, which to many is unknown and dangerous territory, people prefer to give it to men, who have always had it. This is not a surprise for many who have seen this happen time and time again, in the workplace, in the justice system and in the home.

Inequity of power goes back to the beginning of time, when women, physically weaker, and responsible for the birth and caring of children, needed men for survival. They were forced to stand by silently while experiencing and witnessing grave injustices against them and other women. Speaking up was more dangerous than you can imagine, with physical safety, financial security and respectability at risk.

When a woman protested her treatment by a man, it was she, not the perpetrator, who lost everything. Those were the repercussions of speaking up

Why this time is different

Women are tired of those social injustices—finally, as a cohesive, motivated group, we are better placed to do something about it, even though we had to be pushed to the limit before we took action.

Thanks to the brave voices who have spoken up this year—it all changes now.

Danielle Newnham, author of Female Innovators at Work, knows this time has come. She says:

“You see, women have been held back for so long, we lost our identity. We lost the ability to speak up when the very things we knew were wrong took its toll. We kept our silence to keep the peace.”

And now that the silence is broken, and acquiescence has given way to disruption, is Patriarchy finally falling? Will women take their place in building a better world?

The answer is “Yes!”, according to Margaret Mead, who said,

“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.”

44 thoughts on “Women Are Rising in Droves in Government—Does This Mean Patriarchy is Dead?”

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Decadence and regard for no one but the extremely rich and privileged—yep, that sounds a lot like the conditions before the French Revolution! We’re all betting that having more women in positions of power might make a difference, but at the same time, I’m aware that many women have bought into the ‘Trump Machine” too. Let’s hope that decent, forward-looking men and women will begin to erode the power of this president!

  1. a beautifully written and timely post Diane! well done!
    I wish the suffragettes who had tubes rammed down their throats to force feed them …
    could see glimpses of this progress. it’s odd to me that other countries have had women leaders and have survived just fine. at least no worse than with a man at the helm. and at least they had a chance to sit at the big table.
    the US with all its fine fake talk of FREEDOM is a top flight hypocrite. you’ll have no problem as long as you’re a White Male raised in the ranks of the secret societies and the good ol’ boy networks.
    heaven help you if you’re merely a woman or any other minority and you DARE to make a difference or a real contribution. maybe it will finally CHANGE now. maybe the time has come.

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      It’s still dangerous for women to speak up, tammy j, as we witnessed during the Kavenaugh proceedings, when one brave and honorable woman was trampled into obscurity. We hope that her heroism was not lost, and that something good may come of what she did, after all. I’m glad you mentioned the suffragettes—women of that era were subjected to all sorts of cruelty in the efforts to subdue them. This happened in the home as well, although the experiences of those women were rarely chronicled. But make no mistake, the men of that era knew what was at stake—that unleashing the power of the vote for women was opening Pandora’s box! Perhaps women of today are just waking up to that fact!

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      And if we are no longer passively dreaming and hoping, maybe taking action will be the next step logical step!

    1. Agreed, Virginia, progress on this issue is hard! If was easy, it would all have been accomplished decades ago! The current President and his insiders may make it close to impossible for the new Congress to change much—but it’s the closest we have come. and I believe we have reason to be optimistic.

  2. Fingers crossed! One blogger (male) has commented on my blog that the #metoo movement has gone too far. I agree we have to be careful about false accusations, but a lot more needs to be done.

    1. Recognizing that there are good, responsible men who are committed to supporting women is one way we can reassure men that we are not attacking them. Admittedly, I didn’t do this in my article. But you are right, Jean, there is so much more to do!

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        Thanks, Jean. I haven’t read all of it yet, but will. It looks like an important, research based article, and deserves a thorough read.

  3. Your writing here is very thought-provoking, Diane, as are the comments.
    I agree that remarkable progress is being made, although slowly, and sometimes we take steps forward…only to take other steps back.
    I’ve also heard some comments that the #MeToo movement has gone too far. Unfortunately, the comments I’ve heard have focused on one-off examples and concern for the ‘demise of the white man’ as opposed to the true issues at hand.

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      I think that now, with more women entering politics, and possibly some real progress being made to benefit all women in areas of economic and social equality, the #MeToo movement will cool down. The marches needed to happen, the passion and the rhetoric needed to be expressed, and hopefully now we can all step back and see what has been gained, and what still needs to be done. It’s not over by any means, but it has been a good start. I have many men in my family who don’t feel threatened, and are fully supportive of the women’s movement, as all strong, confident men are. Thank you Donna, for your sensitive, thoughtful comment.

  4. I hope the recent successes of women in the US elections can be sustained and can lead to improvements in the way the US is governed. As you say, their President is evidence that preferring an unqualified man over a highly qualified woman is a huge (or should I say yuge?) mistake. But it isn’t simply a matter of gender, is it? I don’t think there are many here who regard our female Prime Minister as a success!

    1. Still the Lucky Few

      Theresa May has apparently made a few mistakes, and doesn’t have a popular reputation. I hate to admit that I haven’t followed her as closely as I’ve followed our North American leaders. But you make a good point, Clive—gender does not guarantee quality! She sounds as if she truly cares about the citizens she governs, however, and that, to me, is important, sensitivity being a main quality I would look for in a female politician. But all politicians, as terrific as they may seem, still have ‘feet of clay’, even our own cherished Justin Trudeau!

      1. She has made many mistakes, usually on the biggest issues. Hubris led her to go for a general election last year which cost her an overall majority, since when she has led a government which has become ever more obstinate and lacking any vision. The current view here is that she will fail to get parliamentary approval on the deal she has negotiated with the EU and that will bring about the downfall of her government. She may give the impression of caring when compared with the likes of Trump, but her government as a whole is widely held here to be uncaring and only interested in protecting the wealthy. Sound familiar? I’d look for sensitivity in any politician regardless of gender, but there are very few who exhibit it. I think that may be something to do with the size of the ego required to be a politician, which leaves little room for more desirable human qualities. We should at least expect competence, which has been in very short supply in the US and UK of late!

        1. Still the Lucky Few

          “Uncaring and only interested in protecting the wealthy”—Et Tu, Teresa? And yes, I remember her calling for an early vote last year. That was, as you say, pure hubris! It does take a huge ego to run for office, which should automatically discount anyone as a good choice, but really, Clive, it is one of the risks of democracy—and who wants the alternative, dictatorship?

    2. Your recent elections and the Me Too movement the latter of which had its repercussions over here too certainly indicates a more assertive womanhood wanting its place in the sun. Patriarchy however is not likely to die anytime soon in many societies and more so in ours particularly. It is sad but, an indisputable fact. There is a long way of struggle ahead for Indian women.

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        I’m sorry to hear that, but I’m sure you have good reasons for saying so. Men are so entrenched in power now, that it will take inordinate determination and strength, and inordinate good luck to unseat them. And yes, the road ahead will be long and difficult!

    3. Great post and good dialogue with your readers. While I don’t think that patriarchy is dead (yet) I do think it’s bending to the will for balance and equality. As a woman of a certain age, I so appreciate being able to pass the torch of advocacy and activism to this younger generation of women who are hell-bent on doing good and doing it right. Thanks for another thoughtful post.

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        Amen to passing on the torch, Stephanie! I just don’t have the energy to do all that again! I do believe that some men are bending to the will of the movement—with the obvious exceptions!

    4. Well done, Diane! Patriarchy is certainly not dead worldwide, but it appears to be suffering from a fatal illness here in the northern hemisphere of the Americas. Most women living here have had enough of unqualified men ruling over women’s lives. Thanks for your post!

      1. Wow! Great endorsement from someone like you, Rin! Most of us, if given a few moments, can recall one or more times when we were ‘passed over’ by the authorities because we weren’t men. I recall one painful time when, fresh from finishing my Masters, I applied for a supervisory job (in a very challenging special education position), and was shortlisted. Since I was the only person with a degree in my small school district, and since I had a solid background in that particular disciple, I thought I had a terrific chance of having the job. Not so, I eventually learned. The guy who won the position had no degree, no courses in special education and no experience working with challenged children. When I confronted the Superintendent about his choice, I was told that this man had ‘good relating skills’ since he was the school basketball coach. Go figure. Obviously, some twenty years later, I am still stung!

    5. I taught special education at the junior high level and had a student who grabbed me on the chest and between the legs (front and back) 50-70 times a day, for 6 months. (It would have been longer if I had not gone on medical leave the last 3 months of the school year). He clawed my hands until the bled, on a daily basis, and left scars from clawing my chest twice. From the beginning, I was told “Do not react in any way whatsoever.” Two different men who were supposed to be helping devise strategies for working with this student said, “Remember not to react. I know it is uncomfortable.”

      I was floored. Would they EVER think of telling a man, “I know it is uncomfortable,” if someone were grabbing him between the legs, repeatedly?

      That was my MeToo, and it started during #metoo. I never believed in “rape culture” or any of that, until I experienced such blatant sexism and mistreatment first hand. It’s gone too far, and something has to change.

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        That’s a terrible story, Bethany. People who work with disabled youth (and it sounds like this person was), in hospital emergency rooms, and in prisons, are in the front lines, and need to be protected from abuse. In my view, you shouldn’t have been working alone—a team working together has a better chance of being safe. And where was your supervisor when this was going down? People in authority prefer workers to just quit, rather than make a fuss and hold them accountable. Yes, there is a culture of abuse when people with little power are in a tough spot—I hope you had some counselling and were able to overcome this experience. There are many great jobs to be had in teaching, especially in special education, and I would hate to see you not use your training and expertise.

        1. It was really a complete breakdown of everything. I eventually ended up with an aide who was CPI certified (and I eventually was sent to get my certification renewed as well). But I was horribly understaffed and ended up being alone with the kid a lot. And the supervisors….you can’t see me rolling my eyes right now. I made lots of noise and sought a lot of support (I won’t go into details publicly…yet…), but the laws weren’t in my favor. And I do have an excellent therapist, who was happy to sign my FMLA paperwork! 😉 Right now I’m substitute teaching, which I LOVE. I was unhappy with the time committment in teaching full time, even before last year, so teaching part time has been a welcome change.

    6. There is so much to say here as I read the comments to your thoughtful post. Two are uppermost in my mind: Bethany, I hold in my heart you and all who have been treated with such dismissal. The second: I cannot agree with some that the MeToo movement has gone too far. Is the evidence that at times someone may be seen as unfairly challenged? (Kavenah?) Or someone actually innocent so charged? If so that happens every day when anyone is accused of anything. Are some people just uncomfortable having to read about it? Is it just something that was important for a while but now is just yadda yadda…No. There should be no attempt to silence anyone. We have only begun to hear from the very strongest of voices. I’ll jump off my soap box now. Even I didn’t see all that coming from me this morning!!!

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        Alexandra, thank you for your very definite, strong statement! I admit that, when some challenge me and say that the #MeToo movement has gone to far, I tend to waver a bit and wonder, maybe it has? But no, you are right—there is so much more to hear, say and do!

        1. When you host a forum it is natural to want everyone in the ‘room’ to feel comfortable contributing. Unfortunately we can often wander off a bit. But there are many of us who want to support the struggle as you and I do. It’s always painful and often nothing, or not enough, is done. Now there are voices who are rising up in support of ‘poor guys and men” who just may be embarrassed. It’s Time!! If guilty, they can learn to live with shame.

    7. “What Donald Trump represented, and what he still represents, is the unequal balance of power given to unqualified, undeserving, and ill-equipped men.” — you’re not kidding!

      And, if it weren’t for the foolish electoral college system, Trump wouldn’t be in power. After all, Hillary Clinton got more votes than him.

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        True, Neil, and it still hurts! The injustice of it is something we should all be concerned about.

    8. You raise important thoughts. This is a major point in time for women, a strong beginning, but we have a long way to go staying on this road without being diverted or having forces drive us elsewhere. I want to see long term consistency which will mean years before I’m comfortable we’re all just being assessed as people, and issues — gender, color, etc. have ceased to be the most significant focus.

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        So true, Joared. We are constantly being distracted by life, but today we have the added distractions of social media, and politicians whose main objective seems to be to veer us away from the important issues! But we have stayed on course before, and I’m convinced we can do it again!

    9. Hi Diane! I am just finally getting around to reading this and completely agree with you. Our time as women has come and I am very grateful. Of course that doesn’t mean it is OVER or that we can just sit back and reap the benefits, but seeing such a change is good for the soul…and good for our country…and good for the world in general. If DT has done nothing more than wake us up…maybe that’s a good thing??? (yes, I’m always the optimist!!!!) ~Kathy

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        You are the consummate optimist Kathy—that’s what we love about you! No, it’s not over, by a long shot, but it’s a wonderful beginning!

      1. Still the Lucky Few

        I agree, Trippe. But to restate an overused phrase, “You have to begin somewhere”! Thanks for your comment!

    Comments are closed.

    © 2024 Diane Dahli All Rights Reserved | WordPress site by Quadra Street Designs